- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Winter Olympics
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: Isn't Jay Cutler a top 5 NFL Quarterback?
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:46 pm to L S Usetheforce
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:46 pm to L S Usetheforce
quote:
We can say the same for Brees though......
ok? i didnt say anything about Brees
0
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:46 pm to RummelTiger
What the frick?
Again, name 5 QB's you'd take over Cutler today.
You can't do it. Anybody who says Tom Brady is just ridiculous. Why not Peyton Manning? Why not Brett Favre? They're all on the downside of their careers. Cutler is just entering his prime.
Personally I'd take Cutler over anybody save for Matt Ryan and possibly Drew Brees. He'd beat out Cassel and Rivers and Eli and Big Ben.
Again, name 5 QB's you'd take over Cutler today.
You can't do it. Anybody who says Tom Brady is just ridiculous. Why not Peyton Manning? Why not Brett Favre? They're all on the downside of their careers. Cutler is just entering his prime.
Personally I'd take Cutler over anybody save for Matt Ryan and possibly Drew Brees. He'd beat out Cassel and Rivers and Eli and Big Ben.
This post was edited on 3/10/09 at 9:49 pm
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:47 pm to mmjones87
rings = team stat
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:48 pm to AlejandroInHouston
quote:
so you'd take Kurt Warner over Cutler by that retarded rationale
So the fact that Tom Brady has 3 super bowl rings doesnt mean he is a top 5 quarterback?
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:49 pm to AlejandroInHouston
quote:
Again, name 5 QB's you'd take over Cutler today.
Peyton
Brady
Brees
Rivers
Rodgers
Romo
Ryan
McNabb
Cassell
Rothlisberger
This post was edited on 3/10/09 at 9:50 pm
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:49 pm to AlejandroInHouston
quote:
Cutler today.
I would take Peyton Manning over Jay Cutler....today.
Which is it?...over the second half of their careers? or.....today?
We're using your own criteria here...
This post was edited on 3/10/09 at 9:50 pm
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:50 pm to Lester Earl
Jesus Christ. Half of these guys have fewer than 5 years left in the NFL.
Rodgers, Rivers, Ryan, and Cassel at least meet the age requirements. I disgree that they are better than Cutler though (save for Ryan).
Edit to add: By saying "who would you take TODAY" you're obviously inheriting the remainder of their careers. You wouldn't take Peyton Manning over Jay Cutler because you're getting 4 years instead of 10 (and $15 million a year instead of $5).
Rodgers, Rivers, Ryan, and Cassel at least meet the age requirements. I disgree that they are better than Cutler though (save for Ryan).
Edit to add: By saying "who would you take TODAY" you're obviously inheriting the remainder of their careers. You wouldn't take Peyton Manning over Jay Cutler because you're getting 4 years instead of 10 (and $15 million a year instead of $5).
This post was edited on 3/10/09 at 9:52 pm
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:50 pm to AlejandroInHouston
quote:
Why not Brett Favre?
Why would we name someone who is retired?
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:51 pm to BayouBengals03
quote:
Rodgers is bad, just bad.
Link?
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:51 pm to AlejandroInHouston
quote:In the afc west he is...
Isn't Jay Cutler a top 5 NFL Quarterback
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:51 pm to AlejandroInHouston
quote:
Jesus Christ. Half of these guys have fewer than 5 years left in the NFL.
...this doesn't matter because you qualified it with 'today', which means 'at their present ability'.
Jay Cutler has type II diabetes...how do we know that in 5 years he's going to have only one leg?.....
This post was edited on 3/10/09 at 9:53 pm
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:52 pm to ToplessTenors4evuh
quote:
...this doesn't matter because you qualified it with 'today', which means 'at their present ability'.
What? So because I said "who would you take today" that means that every NFL QB is automatically aged 25 and has 10 good years left? That's ridiculous.
quote:
Jay Cutler has type II diabetes...how do we know that in 5 years he's going to have only one leg?.....
Umm, because it's two-thousand and fricking NINE. He's more likely to catch polio for Christ sakes.
This post was edited on 3/10/09 at 9:54 pm
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:53 pm to AlejandroInHouston
quote:
Again, name 5 QB's you'd take over Cutler today.
Manning, Brady, Brees, Ryan, Rivers, Ben...
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:53 pm to mmjones87
5 better than Cutler? Simple:
Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Big Ben, Drew Brees, Warner
I dont think any of those are arguable. If it was just for one year, he isnt a clear cut over McNabb, Hasselback, Palmer, etc. If you are talking about drafting a guy for the next 10 years, he would be in the argument with Rivers, Eli, Ryan, Romo, Flacco, etc replacing Warner.
I pull for him, but he isnt elite yet.
Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Big Ben, Drew Brees, Warner
I dont think any of those are arguable. If it was just for one year, he isnt a clear cut over McNabb, Hasselback, Palmer, etc. If you are talking about drafting a guy for the next 10 years, he would be in the argument with Rivers, Eli, Ryan, Romo, Flacco, etc replacing Warner.
I pull for him, but he isnt elite yet.
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:53 pm to AlejandroInHouston
quote:
That's ridiculous.
I think this concept was well established back in the first post of this thread...
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:55 pm to Hooligan33
I give up.
Take a reading comprehension test sometime. I'm going to watch some basketball.
This post was edited on 3/10/09 at 9:55 pm
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:55 pm to ToplessTenors4evuh
quote:
Okay, so you'd take Kurt Warner over Cutler by that retarded rationale. You're a fricking moron and are eliminated from this thread.
Hell yeah I would, Warner's release and decision making is light years ahead of Cutler......
And what rationale are you speaking of, you asked me to make a list and I did?
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:56 pm to AlejandroInHouston
you said today dude
and i would take any of those dude over the 5 next years over cutler
and i would take any of those dude over the 5 next years over cutler
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:56 pm to Lester Earl
That was my point also Earl.........but we all fricking idiots so..........
Posted on 3/10/09 at 9:57 pm to Lester Earl
quote:
you said today dude
glad to know I wasn't the only one that 'comprehended' that incorrectly.....
Page 2 of 5
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News