- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: Off Season: Ranking LSU QBs
Posted on 3/29/21 at 12:36 pm to PenguinPubes
Posted on 3/29/21 at 12:36 pm to PenguinPubes
quote:
30. Jordan Jefferson
One of the most winningest QB's in LSU history.
0
Posted on 3/29/21 at 12:53 pm to mmcgrath
quote:Russell was one of the absolute best QBs at LSU.
Russell imo has been overrated by the fan base because he was the number one pick as much as people think he is a bust because of the flame out. He was drafted mostly on potential, not on what he did at LSU.
Russell
QB Rating: 147.94
Comp %: 61.86%
TD:INT: 52:21 (2.47)
YPA: 8.31
Flynn
QB Rating: 133.04
Comp %: 56.06%
TD:INT: 31:13 (2.38)
YPA: 7.08
Hodson
QB Rating: 136.32
Comp %: 57.95%
TD:INT: 69:41 (1.68)
YPA: 7.84
This post was edited on 3/29/21 at 2:39 pm
Posted on 3/29/21 at 1:13 pm to Salviati
quote:agreed.
Russell was one of the absolute best QBs at LSU.
Russell
QB Rating: 147.94
Comp %: 61.86%
TD:INT: 52:21 (2.47)
YPA: 8.31
People's opinions are wrongly affected by his NFL disaster, but none of that matters. He crushed it when he was here. And not only racked up impressive stats, but he made some big-time pressure game-winning throws.
Posted on 3/29/21 at 1:16 pm to blueridgeTiger
JaMarcus Russell threw the prettiest pass I have ever seen, at any level.
There’s no way he shouldn’t be right after Burrow.
There’s no way he shouldn’t be right after Burrow.
Posted on 3/29/21 at 1:17 pm to blueridgeTiger
No Andrew Hatch? List is shite
Posted on 3/29/21 at 1:28 pm to Lester Earl
quote:
Russel at 8 is lolz
The entire rankings are BS.
All the QBs who played for Charlie Mac and Miles should get a boost.
Anyone who would rate Burrow ahead of Jones and Hodson does not understand the difference in receiver talent on their teams.
Those three would be at the top of my list.
Posted on 3/29/21 at 1:35 pm to Gus007
quote:you can't base rankings on what you think QBs would do within another scheme or with other talent. If so, then the entire ranking is even more guesswork than it is now.
Anyone who would rate Burrow ahead of Jones and Hodson does not understand the difference in receiver talent on their teams.
Those three would be at the top of my list.
You have to rank them based on what they actually did on the field, and not guess how they'd do in Brady's system with Chase, Jefferson, CEH, etc.
Posted on 3/29/21 at 1:50 pm to dukke v
quote:
I’d put Hodson at 2.
Idk why you got downvoted for this, numbers back it up, I realize he was a 4 year starter so the numbers are tilted but he smokes Bert Jones.
Posted on 3/29/21 at 1:58 pm to blueridgeTiger
I don't have time to compare stats but these 4...
below these..
is incorrect...
quote:
12. Jeff Wickersham
13. Alan Risher
I would reverse the order of these two.
14. David Woodley
15. Jarrett Lee
below these..
quote:
10. Herb Tyler
11. Danny Etling
is incorrect...
Posted on 3/29/21 at 2:07 pm to klrstix
Jamarcus Russell got absolutely robbed of a Heisman that year. At least he beat Brady Quinn in the bowl to prove it. Russell should definitely be higher on the list. Top 5 easily, top 3 possibly.
Also, Jordan Jefferson is a bit underrated based on his actual career and how successful he was. People mostly remember the title game and the bad moments, but he had some stellar games as well. He was pretty lethal running the ball when he needed to, and he honestly was a lot better than a lot of people want to admit at this point. Lee is a tad high on the list.
Disappointed we don't have an Andrew Hatch sighting on there somewhere (kidding!)
Also, Jordan Jefferson is a bit underrated based on his actual career and how successful he was. People mostly remember the title game and the bad moments, but he had some stellar games as well. He was pretty lethal running the ball when he needed to, and he honestly was a lot better than a lot of people want to admit at this point. Lee is a tad high on the list.
Disappointed we don't have an Andrew Hatch sighting on there somewhere (kidding!)
Posted on 3/29/21 at 2:11 pm to blueridgeTiger
He gets a bad wrap for being one of the biggest busts in NFL history, but as an LSU QB, Jamarcus is to 5.
Just because Mauk and Flynn won national titles doesn’t automatically make them better QBs
Just because Mauk and Flynn won national titles doesn’t automatically make them better QBs
Posted on 3/29/21 at 2:14 pm to okietiger
quote:
There’s no way he shouldn’t be right after Burrow
The can see Hodson being #2 but Russel should be no worse than 3.
Posted on 3/29/21 at 2:19 pm to memphis tiger
I feel like Perilloux would be based on what is on that list
Posted on 3/29/21 at 3:09 pm to klrstix
quote:No.
I don't have time to compare stats but these 4...
NAME . . . Comp% . . . RATING
Joe Burrow . . . 68.54% . . . 173.2
Ryan Perrilloux . . . 65.82% . . . 169.03
Rohan Davey . . . 59.83% . . . 151.16
Zach Mettenberger . . . 61.76% . . . 148.45
JaMarcus Russell . . . 61.81% . . . 147.91
Danny Etling . . . 59.74% . . . 144.36
Herb Tyler . . . 60.70% . . . 141.48
Tommy Hodson . . . 59.07% . . . 138.94
Mike Miley . . . 56.07% . . . 135.75
Matt Mauck . . . 58.60% . . . 135.71
Mickey Guidry . . . 62.04% . . . 133.93
Alan Risher . . . 61.95% . . . 133.40
Matt Flynn . . . 56.06% . . . 133.04
Bert Jones . . . 52.87% . . . 132.73
Jordan Jefferson . . . 58.55% . . . 127.84
Marcus Randall . . . 56.10% . . . 127.57
Felix Lee . . . 52.90% . . . 126.38
Jarrett Lee . . . 56.11% . . . 126.07
Sol Graves . . . 48.11% . . . 119.57
Jesse Daigle . . . 51.26% . . . 118.77
Chad Loup . . . 56.19% . . . 118.64
Andrew Hatch . . . 55.32% . . . 117.11
Jeff Wickersham . . . 58.41% . . . 116.70
Paul Lyons . . . 46.95% . . . 109.07
Jamie Howard . . . 49.14% . . . 106.47
Robbie Mahfouz . . . 48.57% . . . 105.74
David Woodley . . . 49.03% . . . 104.61
Josh Booty . . . 49.28% . . . 104.35
Steve Ensminger . . . 45.16% . . . 102.63
Craig Nall . . . 47.46% . . . 89.08
Carl Otis Trimble . . . 45.00% . . . 87.98
Tim Byrd . . . 50.00% . . . 86.88
Billy Broussard . . . 41.22% . . . 84.75
Pat Lyons . . . 43.49% . . . 81.61
Doug Powell . . . 48.00% . . . 70.13
Ken Moreau . . . 45.45% . . . 68.51
Rick Clausen . . . 41.67% . . . 49.50
This post was edited on 3/29/21 at 3:31 pm
Posted on 3/29/21 at 3:18 pm to atltiger6487
quote:
you can't base rankings on what you think QBs would do within another scheme or with other talent. If so, then the entire ranking is even more guesswork than it is now.
I thought he was asking for opinions. Didn't realize it was opinions based on success of the team.
If that is the criteria.
Rabb, Mauck, Flynn, and Burrow
The rest is just subjective.
Those were best and the trophy room proves it.
Posted on 3/29/21 at 3:25 pm to Gus007
quote:Reading is fundamental.quote:I thought he was asking for opinions. Didn't realize it was opinions based on success of the team.
you can't base rankings on what you think QBs would do within another scheme or with other talent. If so, then the entire ranking is even more guesswork than it is now.
You have to rank them based on what they actually did on the field, and not guess how they'd do in Brady's system with Chase, Jefferson, CEH, etc.
If that is the criteria.
Rabb, Mauck, Flynn, and Burrow
The rest is just subjective.
Those were best and the trophy room proves it.
Your strawman suggests an agenda.
Posted on 3/29/21 at 3:34 pm to blueridgeTiger
A whole lot of stupid on that list. I guess it's based off of success of the team ? There are some awful QBs on that list.... and Bert Jones was the GOAT LSU QB !
Posted on 3/29/21 at 3:40 pm to blueridgeTiger
Gimme Rohan over Mett
Posted on 3/29/21 at 3:42 pm to blueridgeTiger
What I have seen top 10
(edited yards game average rough)
1. Joe Burrow (373)1
2. JaMarcus Russell (240)4
3. Rohan Davey (275)2
4. Zach Mettenberger (250)3
5. Matt Flynn (200)5
6. Matt mauck (200)5
7. Herb Tyler (200)5
8. Danny etling (185)8
9. Marcus randle (100)9
10. Jarret lee (100)9
(If myles completed season at his numbers he would be rated #4 for me, maybe #3 or #2 if he had a little more pocket awareness, he was on a tear averaging over 360 yards per game 10games would have out him over 3600 yards in a 10game season against sec conference schedule)
What could have been
*Myles brennan 360 yards per game his only three starts
*Ryan perilou never started a game but at times he played better and had some better throws that mauck did. If he hadnt made some dumb decisions would have been in the nfl and be up there with burrow davey and russle as best qbs in purp n hold
(edited yards game average rough)
1. Joe Burrow (373)1
2. JaMarcus Russell (240)4
3. Rohan Davey (275)2
4. Zach Mettenberger (250)3
5. Matt Flynn (200)5
6. Matt mauck (200)5
7. Herb Tyler (200)5
8. Danny etling (185)8
9. Marcus randle (100)9
10. Jarret lee (100)9
(If myles completed season at his numbers he would be rated #4 for me, maybe #3 or #2 if he had a little more pocket awareness, he was on a tear averaging over 360 yards per game 10games would have out him over 3600 yards in a 10game season against sec conference schedule)
What could have been
*Myles brennan 360 yards per game his only three starts
*Ryan perilou never started a game but at times he played better and had some better throws that mauck did. If he hadnt made some dumb decisions would have been in the nfl and be up there with burrow davey and russle as best qbs in purp n hold
This post was edited on 3/29/21 at 11:52 pm
Posted on 3/29/21 at 3:44 pm to Lsutigerturner
I guess you never saw Bert Jones play.
Page 2 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News