- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Winter Olympics
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Seeking Dynasty roster advice
Posted on 2/4/23 at 6:30 am
Posted on 2/4/23 at 6:30 am
12tm SF PPR +0.5tep - Start 10
Finished 6th this season and wondering if I should just sell off some assets and punt to 2024 season or hold what I have and attempt a run…
QBs: Murray (main problem), Fields, Trask, Willis, Studham
RB: Swift, Javonte Williams, Pacheco, Brian Robinson, Allgeier, Hassan Haskins, Jordan Mason, some nobodies
WR: DK, DJ Moore, Lazard, Olave, Burks, Metchie, Tyquan Thornton, some trash
TE: Bellinger, Likely, Juwan Johnson, Hooper, Kyler Granson… (ouch)
Thinking about selling Swift, Metcalf, DJ Moore and Pacheco/Brian Robinson if I can, aiming for a 2024 run and beyond. Kyler Murray missing some of next season and even then who knows has me worried. I could throw out a draft pick for a low-end starter to make a run but I don’t think my roster has enough juice as is. Thoughts?
This was a startup this year so I don’t have extra draft picks to throw around yet. Drafting 1.07 (gross) and only picked up an extra 2023 2nd (2.11) during the start up draft
Finished 6th this season and wondering if I should just sell off some assets and punt to 2024 season or hold what I have and attempt a run…
QBs: Murray (main problem), Fields, Trask, Willis, Studham
RB: Swift, Javonte Williams, Pacheco, Brian Robinson, Allgeier, Hassan Haskins, Jordan Mason, some nobodies
WR: DK, DJ Moore, Lazard, Olave, Burks, Metchie, Tyquan Thornton, some trash
TE: Bellinger, Likely, Juwan Johnson, Hooper, Kyler Granson… (ouch)
Thinking about selling Swift, Metcalf, DJ Moore and Pacheco/Brian Robinson if I can, aiming for a 2024 run and beyond. Kyler Murray missing some of next season and even then who knows has me worried. I could throw out a draft pick for a low-end starter to make a run but I don’t think my roster has enough juice as is. Thoughts?
This was a startup this year so I don’t have extra draft picks to throw around yet. Drafting 1.07 (gross) and only picked up an extra 2023 2nd (2.11) during the start up draft
This post was edited on 2/4/23 at 6:34 am
5
Posted on 2/4/23 at 10:18 am to Shameless
Yeah you're squarely in the dead zone
WR: DK, Olave, and Burks are holds.
QB: Fields is interesting. I personally don’t think his value will ever be higher than it is now. He’s someone I’d be looking to dump.
Murray is a hold for now unless you can get a top 6 draft pick.
RB: I’m a swift owner as well, but I’m holding. I’m a strong contender and I invested way too much into him.
WR: DK, Olave, and Burks are holds.
QB: Fields is interesting. I personally don’t think his value will ever be higher than it is now. He’s someone I’d be looking to dump.
Murray is a hold for now unless you can get a top 6 draft pick.
RB: I’m a swift owner as well, but I’m holding. I’m a strong contender and I invested way too much into him.
Posted on 2/4/23 at 11:16 am to VermilionTiger
Yeah my trade problem is I can’t move Robinson, Pacheco, Lazard for shite. I’ve offered Lazard + 2.11 for 2.02-2.05 range and even Lazard for a 3rd with no luck.
If the only other piece I move is DJ Moore it probably doesn’t really move the needle for me IF somebody wants to give me a mid-late 1st for him. He’s honestly a buy-low guy for me in other leagues lol
I feel like I have to either blow it up and build around 3-4 guys + picks or just spend some extra draft capital on the trade market to improve. Holding and drafting with what I have doesn’t seem too promising
If the only other piece I move is DJ Moore it probably doesn’t really move the needle for me IF somebody wants to give me a mid-late 1st for him. He’s honestly a buy-low guy for me in other leagues lol
I feel like I have to either blow it up and build around 3-4 guys + picks or just spend some extra draft capital on the trade market to improve. Holding and drafting with what I have doesn’t seem too promising
This post was edited on 2/4/23 at 11:19 am
Posted on 2/4/23 at 4:40 pm to Shameless
I'd be seeing if you could squeeze some late 2nd capital out of Trask from the Brady manager. Maybe move Fields or Murray for a guy like Mac Jones and some early capital.
You're not terrible at RB, but Swift isn't an RB1. He has all of the pass catching upside and none of the rushing upside. Payton might squeeze all he can out of Williams in Denver and Pacheco, Robinson, and Allgeir all look to have solid roles heading into next year.
Same with the WR room. Solid 1-2 with Metcalf and Moore, with Olave and Burks behind them to grow.
The huge hole you have is at TE. That and Kyler/Swift/Williams injuries are why you finished 6th in scoring. Your roster is solid otherwise and injuries are variable.
In the draft, you should probably be looking at Michael Mayer or Darnell Washington at 7. I'd go Washington personally.
You're not terrible at RB, but Swift isn't an RB1. He has all of the pass catching upside and none of the rushing upside. Payton might squeeze all he can out of Williams in Denver and Pacheco, Robinson, and Allgeir all look to have solid roles heading into next year.
Same with the WR room. Solid 1-2 with Metcalf and Moore, with Olave and Burks behind them to grow.
The huge hole you have is at TE. That and Kyler/Swift/Williams injuries are why you finished 6th in scoring. Your roster is solid otherwise and injuries are variable.
In the draft, you should probably be looking at Michael Mayer or Darnell Washington at 7. I'd go Washington personally.
Posted on 2/7/23 at 4:37 pm to VictoryHill
there are still many variables with combine and NFL draft still to come. But it seems most at this point of the year have a similar top 7 (even without Levis and Richardson getting drafted early), so I would not say 1.07 is “gross”.
Bijan
Bryce/CJS/Gibbs
JSN/QJ/Addison
Any of those should help your team contend in the second half of 2023. Since it’s a startup, the stratification between contenders and pretenders shouldn’t be well defined. I would at least wait until in season, assessing your team against others, to sell players who score points. In 2022 Seattle was going to be terrible and the Rams were going to dominate. Every AFC west game was going to score over 70 points. We often don’t predict things as well as we would like or like to remember.
Bijan
Bryce/CJS/Gibbs
JSN/QJ/Addison
Any of those should help your team contend in the second half of 2023. Since it’s a startup, the stratification between contenders and pretenders shouldn’t be well defined. I would at least wait until in season, assessing your team against others, to sell players who score points. In 2022 Seattle was going to be terrible and the Rams were going to dominate. Every AFC west game was going to score over 70 points. We often don’t predict things as well as we would like or like to remember.
Posted on 2/8/23 at 4:59 am to Shameless
You probably need to hold off for now. Draft best available at 1.07. You will be losing a lot of early games while players come back from injuries from this past season. You should get more value in season from contenders.
Posted on 2/22/23 at 6:12 am to VictoryHill
quote:
In the draft, you should probably be looking at Michael Mayer or Darnell Washington at 7. I'd go Washington personally.
I disagree with investing a first in rookie TEs. I’d rather trade the pick (and maybe more) to get an established TE because they take so long to develop and outside of a handful of guys are a crapshoot every year.
Posted on 2/23/23 at 6:41 am to Shameless
No decisions til after rookie draft
If the Bears draft a QB to replace Fields, I’d consider throwing in the towel. You’ll have nothing at QB, nothing at TE, a bunch of middle of the road at RB, and plus WRs. Kyler won’t be a difference maker next season, if he comes back he’ll be limited as a runner
Javonte likely limited as a runner next season. Those injuries need a full year of play to recover to 100%
So if Fields is replaced, I’m definitely selling the ones you mentioned (might keep DK if Geno gets a long term deal though). Go for a quick reload into 2024
If the Bears draft a QB to replace Fields, I’d consider throwing in the towel. You’ll have nothing at QB, nothing at TE, a bunch of middle of the road at RB, and plus WRs. Kyler won’t be a difference maker next season, if he comes back he’ll be limited as a runner
Javonte likely limited as a runner next season. Those injuries need a full year of play to recover to 100%
So if Fields is replaced, I’m definitely selling the ones you mentioned (might keep DK if Geno gets a long term deal though). Go for a quick reload into 2024
Posted on 3/12/23 at 4:25 pm to Upperdecker
Fields is the most overrated QB I’ve ever seen. The only thing separating him and Zach Wilson is that Fields can run like RG3. Trade him while value is high
Posted on 3/12/23 at 11:53 pm to VictoryHill
quote:
In the draft, you should probably be looking at Michael Mayer or Darnell Washington at 7. I'd go Washington personally
I’d love to know the thought process on drafting Darnell Washington at 1.07. That seems like a terrible idea to me, even in a TEP league.
Posted on 3/13/23 at 9:33 am to Shameless
I would check the temp and see if anyone is super high on DJ Moore after the trade. Fields was an awful passer. I had really high hopes that Moore would either get a QB or end up in a better situation and have a Stefon Diggs-type career arc because I think he might be close to that level of talent.
I would keep Metcalf. Even when hes older and loses a step hes still frickin huge and can be an asset for a team. Think he ages well.
I would move Pacheco and Robinson for sure, yeah.
I'm out on Swift personally but I think most owners are at a point where you feel committed to taking the ride to wherever it goes
I sold Javonte after the injury last year and I'm glad I did. His value has only gotten worse after the news that he might not even play this year because his injury is a lot worse than the Broncos feared. I think you just gotta ride this out if you still own and hope he beats the odds.
I would also sell Allgeier. The Falcons have publicly said they aren't committed to him as a bell cow and by the time you're competitive again they will have moved on and they might end up drafting Gibbs or Bijan this year anyway. I would do this before the draft and just commit to a rebuild.
I would keep Metcalf. Even when hes older and loses a step hes still frickin huge and can be an asset for a team. Think he ages well.
I would move Pacheco and Robinson for sure, yeah.
I'm out on Swift personally but I think most owners are at a point where you feel committed to taking the ride to wherever it goes
I sold Javonte after the injury last year and I'm glad I did. His value has only gotten worse after the news that he might not even play this year because his injury is a lot worse than the Broncos feared. I think you just gotta ride this out if you still own and hope he beats the odds.
I would also sell Allgeier. The Falcons have publicly said they aren't committed to him as a bell cow and by the time you're competitive again they will have moved on and they might end up drafting Gibbs or Bijan this year anyway. I would do this before the draft and just commit to a rebuild.
Posted on 3/13/23 at 9:40 am to VictoryHill
quote:
In the draft, you should probably be looking at Michael Mayer or Darnell Washington at 7. I'd go Washington personally.
I'm pretty high on both but thats really rich for Washington in a Superflex and probably for Mayer too pending landing spot.
Besides Bijan, Washington is the player I'm most confident in being a good real life football player in this entire draft, but I'm skeptical about him for fantasy. His worst case scenario is that hes a great run blocking TE for a team who occasionally blows up and catches touchdowns/makes a big highlight run after catch. His ceiling is what, another Gronk? So I totally get the appeal, but he just doesn't have the pass catching production you'd like to see. Gronk had 6 touchdowns as a Freshman, 10 as a sophomore, and missed his entire junior year. Darnell has 3 CAREER touchdowns. And yeah, comparing him to the GOAT of his position probably isn't fair, I get it.
If people are gonna overdraft those two though, I'll gladly pivot to other guys at the position later. Musgrave or Kincaid are going to absolutely blow up if they get to the right situation. Like one of those two on the Cowboys? Yes please. LaPorta from Iowa is really nice too, as well as the South Dakota guy and the ODU guy.
Page 1 of 1
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News