Domain: tiger-web1.srvr.media3.us Shingle or metal roof? | Page 2 | O-T Lounge
Started By
Message

re: Shingle or metal roof?

Posted on 10/1/24 at 5:30 pm to
Posted by DMAN1968
Member since Apr 2019
12796 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 5:30 pm to
quote:

I'll live in a tent before I ever have another metal roof.

Why?
Posted by Lsutigerturner
Member since Dec 2016
7214 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 6:04 pm to
I thought all you would need to do is replace all the attaching screws with new rubber gasket screws and redo any flashing and pay a Inspectors to come and inspect for wind mitigation.. at least that what I thought you needed to do
Posted by Armymann50
Playing with my
Member since Sep 2011
22227 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 6:15 pm to
I used this for my roof.
Posted by BHM
Member since Jun 2012
3896 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 6:27 pm to
My metal roof has been through several hail storms one of which left a few minor dents on my car and truck. Roof had no damage while a few shingles roofs around were beat to shite.

If you go metal make sure you get 22 gauge and not the thinner 26 or 29 gauge. My roof is off white and reflects a lot of heat.

As far as there being cosmetic damaged not covered, the same applies to the ugly black mold that grows on asphalt shingles roofs. Ugly as hell and insurance will not pay to replace it.
Posted by Turnblad85
Member since Sep 2022
4969 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 6:35 pm to
quote:

had a metal roof that was about 26 years old, and their insurance was threatening to drop them due to the age of the roof.




I know of a similar story except the 26ga roof was 15yo. Perfectly fine roof but the insurance DGAF
Posted by Boudreauboudreaugoly
Land of the Rice n Son
Member since Oct 2017
2785 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 6:38 pm to
Galvalume roof here. Installed on new build 30 years ago. Just had it inspected due to a couple minor leaks around sewer vents. Had all roof penetrations redone and all roofing screws replaced. ($6500) Galvalume still good for another 30. Single best value expense invested in the original build.
Posted by Kjnstkmn
Vermilion Parish
Member since Aug 2020
20947 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 7:00 pm to
Posted by shiftworker
LP
Member since Dec 2011
5297 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 7:42 pm to
Forgive my ignorance, but what is that?
Posted by Kim Jong Ir
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2008
54986 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 8:06 pm to
quote:

Thatch is the way to go.


They are doing great things with Cherokee Hair these days.
Posted by DownshiftAndFloorIt
Here
Member since Jan 2011
71567 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 8:07 pm to
A heavy gauge steel roof is where it's at.
Posted by N2cars
Member since Feb 2008
38557 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 8:25 pm to
Constant maintenance.

Metal contracts and expands in the heat here leading to leaks.

More difficult to insulate.
No OTA antenna in the attic/ worse cell phone reception
More difficult to find installers that know WTF they're doing.

A properly installed shingle roof system is still the best way to go, although all shingle warranties are a joke.
Posted by olgoi khorkhoi
priapism survivor
Member since May 2011
16564 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 8:29 pm to
quote:

Well I agree with insurance here. You aren’t paying insurance for a pretty roof, you’re paying insurance for a sound roof.




You're paying insurance to make you whole in case of a loss (minus the deductible). If the hail damage causes a loss of value, then they should cover it.
Posted by cgrand
HAMMOND
Member since Oct 2009
47379 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 8:33 pm to
my house was built in 1979
I replaced the original metal roof this summer with a new one

that’s a good investment. It will last until I die
Posted by SixthAndBarone
Member since Jan 2019
10869 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 8:34 pm to
quote:

You're paying insurance to make you whole in case of a loss (minus the deductible). If the hail damage causes a loss of value, then they should cover it.


What’s the loss of value, the look of your roof? A sheet of metal protects your home the same as an ugly sheet of metal.
Posted by Rza32
Member since Nov 2008
4401 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 8:35 pm to
Tin
Posted by highcotton2
Alabama
Member since Feb 2010
10424 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 9:11 pm to
quote:

Shingle or metal roof?


Why not metal shingles?

Posted by Armymann50
Playing with my
Member since Sep 2011
22227 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 9:37 pm to
2" insulation covered 26ga sheet metal both sides.great for roofs.
Posted by baldona
Florida
Member since Feb 2016
23770 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 9:54 pm to
From a simple ROI perspective there’s almost no chance that a metal roof is worth it. It’s more expensive and the any person is not going to benefit from a roof that lasts 25+ years over one that lasts 15 years. If you are older and retired and dead set it’s your forever home than sure, if you have money to burn do it metal is going to most likely be the most protective.
Posted by Spankum
Miss-sippi
Member since Jan 2007
61267 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 10:00 pm to
quote:

The 2 metal roofs in my neighborhood were both deemed "cosmetic" damage and not covered by insurance.


Honestly, that is pretty shitty on all involved that you only find this out after it happens. Lots of sorry frickers knew about this at the time of installation (salesmen, roofing installers, insurance, etc.) and apparently they don’t tell you this.

On the bright side, someone should invent some “hammered” finish or something that doesn’t readily show dents. It might look kind of cool…
Posted by olgoi khorkhoi
priapism survivor
Member since May 2011
16564 posts
Posted on 10/1/24 at 10:41 pm to
quote:

What’s the loss of value, the look of your roof? A sheet of metal protects your home the same as an ugly sheet of metal.



When someone hits you at low speed and dents your car but your car still functions, what is the loss?
first pageprev pagePage 2 of 3Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram